11/12/2025
“When a horse is calm and understands what is being asked of them, they don’t buck with a rider. Not because I train them not to, but because they don’t feel the need to.”
Celebratory bucks.
I don't believe in celebratory bucks, because I don't have bucks show up under saddle very often.
I don't punish bucks, or buck a horse out. I don't use restrictive techniques to prevent a horse from bucking, and I definitely don't use oppresive gadgetry. A buck is feedback that needs to be addressed,bnot repressed.
I still don't have bucks come up with any regularity. This photo was one of the three times I rode a buck over the last 5 years. Remeber my job is to start young horses, and work with troubled horses. Lots of them. It wasn't a celebratory buck. This moment wasn't from pain or anxiety either, but the other bucks I experienced were. All three were, however, the results of an error on my part.
I would say the most common reason I see for horses bucking is anxiety, but that doesn't mean it is the most common reason. Before I work with a horse with bucking issues, I ask owners to provide a clear vet and physio report. This means that I don't end up seeing as many of the pain related cases, as they are identified before I am needed. Pain may be the cause for bucking just as often as anxiety is. Saddle fit, injury or chronic pain.
Anxiety is the overwhelming cause for bucking that I see, but it is wide ranging. A horse may buck when it gets scared and can't get away from a rider holding them in, but it can also get anxious when it doesn't understand what is being asked of it.
For example, a cue for an canter transition. Kicking, or whipping to get the canter is not a communication, it is a forceful manipulation. A horse might stumble on the right answer and canter to get away from that force, but often they will get anxious about it and buck.
So, an anxious horse trying to get away, but being held, or an anxious horse not wanting to go, but being forced to,
might buck.
So what is the other reason? Like the horse in this photo. This guy used to struggle to take a united canter, and would buck to 'organize his legs'.
It is something I usually address on the ground, with exercises to help prepare for the canter depart. I am working on some videos on these exercises for my Patreon page, but it's obviously not in the scope of this article.
On this occasion I had a great photographer on hand and she asked me to canter. I knew I hadn't worked on this youngsters canter depart enough, but wisdom left the building, and I did it anyway. The smile was not glee at riding a buck, it was me laughing at my own stupidity.
It is usually around this point in the discussion about celebratory bucks that someone points out that horses run and buck from excitement when loose in their fields.
They do, and there is a function of this behavior.
If you have even seen. group of horses turned into a new pasture, you would have seen the run, kick and buck as they cover the entire area in a few seconds. They are in a heightened state, and this practice is designed to flush predators from long grass, while the herd is in a heightened state of alert.
I don't want to be riding a horse in that mental state. There have been studies on how often equestrians misread anxiety as excitement in horses, and this phenomenon adds to the celebratory buck myth.
When a horse is calm and understands what is being asked of then, they don't buck with a rider. Not because I train them not to, but because they don't feel the need to.
Photo credit: Catherine Grace Jackson