02/04/2024
There are plenty of reasons to love a black and white photograph… but stick around for a moment, let’s do a deep dive…
(Pictured 10 favorite b/w photographs from my 2023 wedding season, long year-in-review post linked in bio)
Beginning from first principles, what is it that makes a photograph good? Well, it is better than the other photographs taken or untaken… the moments 1/60 second before or after, the compositions shifted a bit to the left or the right, up or down. But that’s nearly tautological…
What makes a particular composition and moment singe the memory of the viewer? I’d say it’s unity of being, with a combined legibility and resistance. The viewer knows what an excellent photograph is about (legibility) but, the viewer understands that there is a deeper meaning that escapes their grasp beyond the initial legibility (resistance.) The unity of being implies a sense of wholeness through complimentary lines and tones and patterns etc. This is also easier to achieve with the omission of color.
Black and white images can help to isolate emotion, gesture, movement from the noise of color, simply by the subtraction of color, but also through marking a photograph as distinctly not a true-to-life view of the real world. A black and white photograph announces itself as an interpretation of our world, a step outside of it.
Please feel free to add to my incomplete reflections in the comments!