12/04/2024
Greetings, everyone – over the years of serving as Moderator of the CPWAs, I’ve tried to be as transparent as possible regarding the processes by which the winners of the Awards are determined. One aspect of those processes I’ve gotten more questions about than any other would be how the Panelists are chosen.
After the 2023 winners were announced I had a conversation with a very astute member of our community who asked that question specifically. I described to them what I typically look for in a Panelist during recruitment; things like name value (in being able to draw people to the CPWAs by association), experience level, and expressed knowledge of the territory. The conversation evolved and then another question came up.
“Have you ever thought of letting the fans pick the Panel?”
To be frank, my first thought was “Oh, boy…”, and not necessarily in an excited sense. I’d never considered that as an option and it seemed like the potential for becoming a mess, nevertheless my mind went into trying to decide if it was feasible. Given that we are already utilizing a similar scenario to help pick the Finalists for the Awards, I feel like it is.
That said, with the 2024 CPWAs and for the first time ever the Panel will be made up of individuals selected by you, the fans.
The process for determining the 2024 CPWA Panel will be as follows:
· A Panelist Nominations thread will be published in the Official CPWA Facebook Group on Monday, April 15
· Members of the group will be asked to make a reply to this thread with the names of NO MORE THAN SIX (6) Panelist Nominees
· Replies to the thread going against this directive will have only the first 6 names considered, all others will be dropped
· The Panelist Nomination thread will be open for one full week (7 days)
· At the end of the Panelist Nomination period the results will be tallied
· The top 6 Panelist Nominees by virtue of the number of individual nominations will be regarded as “potential Panelists”
· These potential Panelists will be asked for their consent to participate (it is only proper to consider the possibility that they may not want to be involved)
· Potential Panelists who consent to participate will be confirmed
· Potential Panelists who choose not to participate will be removed from consideration with the next-highest ranking potential Panelist from the Nominations results being given an opportunity to be involved
· Confirmed Panelists will not be eligible for any CPWA Award Categories
· The confirmed Panel for the 2024 CPWAs will be announced once the Panel Nominations process has been completed
When it comes to who makes an ideal Panelist, the qualities I’ve sought when recruiting Panelists in the past were things like:
· Ties to the local independent professional wrestling scene of the Carolinas (such as being a podcaster/media member, trainer, wrestler, referee, photographer, etc.)
· Knowledge of promotions and talent in the territory
· Potential name value (which could help in bringing attention to the Awards)
· The level of credibility they would attach to the legacy of the Awards
Please don’t make a submission along the lines of “John Cena, Undertaker, El Generico, Shockmaster, the KISS Demon, and the Gobbletygooker.”
It should also be pointed out that one of the parameters I worked off of in the past was that an individual or entity may not serve on the Panel more than once in a 3-year period. With that in mind, the individuals below should not be considered as potential Panelists for the 2024 CPWAS:
· Tracy Myers
· William Roberts
· Joe Blumenfeld
· LaBron Kozone
· Michael Elliott
· Palmetto Championship Wrestling owners (Shane Dorr, Jonathan Winburn & Elliot Poston)
· Chad McDaniel
· Keri Craven
· Bret Wolverton
· Tim Enlow
· Mark de Gruchy
· TK Stark
· Dave Foster
· Yolonda Wright
· Dan Schram
· Ryan Zudonyi
· Smash the Mat Podcast (Jay5, G-Moniy, DB & Mr. Magnificent)
· Rob Killjoy
I realize this is a lot to work with and to consider, however I am fully onboard with giving this scenario a fair shake. If it winds up falling flat, at least we tried, and if it’s well-received then we may incorporate this into our By-Laws as the new way forward when it comes to selecting the Panel.
As always, I thank you for continuing to support the CPWAs. 2024 will be the 10th year for the Awards. Some things related to the professional wrestling industry don’t last 10 months so the fact that we’ve been running this long means a lot to me, personally, and I’d like to think they mean a lot to others in our community as well.
There have been many challenges over the years in keeping this ship going. There have been moments where I considered handing this off to someone else or hanging it up altogether. It’s tough to see something you’re passionate about be criticized, in this case often by the very people to which the Awards are intended to show appreciation. Through it all what has brought me back to the CPWAs is my continued adulation for the men and women who’ve given me so much enjoyment through the artform that is professional wrestling. I’ve been around the Carolinas’ indie scene for more than 20 years and I’m looking forward to seeing what the remainder of 2024 has in store for us all.
We’ll see you at the matches!