The Fish Store

The Fish Store The Fish Store is home to Long Island's freshest seafood market and restaurant. Along with great customer service - it is a combination that can't be beat.
(252)

Whether cooking yourself, grabbing to go or sitting down to a delicious freshly prepared meal in our dining room - our food and friendly staff will be sure to please. Started in 1978, this family business is located in the center of Bayport on the corner of Montauk Highway and Bayport Avenue. The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, dining in our new restaurant,

catering and more. Through our commitment, experience and expertise The Fish Store has established a business relationship with our customers that will last a lifetime! The Fish Store is a proud member of the Bayport-Blue Point Chamber of Commerce.

Long Island Restaurant Week at The Fish Store starts today and ends on February 2. Three delicious course of your choic...
01/26/2025

Long Island Restaurant Week at The Fish Store starts today and ends on February 2. Three delicious course of your choice for $46.00, including our entree of Shellfish Marinara Fra Diablo - shrimp, bay scallops, clams and mussels served in a Fra Diablo sauce over linguini.

Come shop with us at South Shore Farmers Market at Bayport Flower Houses today!
01/25/2025

Come shop with us at South Shore Farmers Market at Bayport Flower Houses today!

New Orleans crawfish cakes! Always something new and delicious at The Fish Store!
01/22/2025

New Orleans crawfish cakes! Always something new and delicious at The Fish Store!

We have a delayed opening today - 10 am. See you then, it's the perfect day for our soups!
01/20/2025

We have a delayed opening today - 10 am. See you then, it's the perfect day for our soups!

Don't miss our Long Island Restaurant Week - it will be delicious!
01/20/2025

Don't miss our Long Island Restaurant Week - it will be delicious!

Your taste buds are in for a treat! 🍴 Long Island Restaurant Week is bringing the best of local cuisine straight to your plate. Whether it’s seafood, steak, or sweets, this is the week to indulge. Where are you eating first? 🍤🍰

🪶 Shands General
🪶 SNAPS RESTAURANT
🪶 Plori Restaurant
🪶 The Fish Store

01/18/2025

We are at Bayport Flower Houses today for South Shore Farmers Market! Hope to see you!

Use that holiday gift of a gift card to The Fish Store today - it's National Use Your Gift Card Day! Good in our fish m...
01/18/2025

Use that holiday gift of a gift card to The Fish Store today - it's National Use Your Gift Card Day! Good in our fish market or restaurant.

Fresh halibut about to be cut! Can’t get any fresher!!!
01/18/2025

Fresh halibut about to be cut! Can’t get any fresher!!!

Thanks for this review! "The Fish Store has the best lobster tails around! Sushi grade fresh fish and more.That’s why ...
01/17/2025

Thanks for this review!
"The Fish Store has the best lobster tails around! Sushi grade fresh fish and more.
That’s why I’m giving it 5 stars."

This time of year - you need soup! We have a huge and delicious selection of homemade soups served in our restaurant or...
01/13/2025

This time of year - you need soup! We have a huge and delicious selection of homemade soups served in our restaurant or take out.

National Oysters Rockefeller Day is today! Come and get them! Oysters covered in bacon, spinach and feta - broiled to ...
01/10/2025

National Oysters Rockefeller Day is today! Come and get them! Oysters covered in bacon, spinach and feta - broiled to perfection.

You have been spotted with TFS sticker! If this your car, please come in because you have won a $20 gift card to The Fi...
01/08/2025

You have been spotted with TFS sticker! If this your car, please come in because you have won a $20 gift card to The Fish Store! Thank you for being a loyal customer. Get your free TFS sticker and if our crew spots it - you might win a gift card too!

Yes - we do have scrumptious desserts! Thanks for the review =)"Great little restaurant with good service and even bett...
01/07/2025

Yes - we do have scrumptious desserts! Thanks for the review =)

"Great little restaurant with good service and even better food. DO NOT PASS UP the rice pudding. Even if you have to take it to go. Best anywhere!"

Happy New Year! We are closed today. Thank you to my employees, friends and family who helped make the holiday season ...
01/01/2025

Happy New Year! We are closed today. Thank you to my employees, friends and family who helped make the holiday season a success! And most of all thanks to all of you for your support this past year and looking forward to an amazing 2025!

Happy New Year's Eve! Our fish market and restaurant is open today 9 am to 9 pm. We will be closed on New Year's Day. ...
12/31/2024

Happy New Year's Eve! Our fish market and restaurant is open today 9 am to 9 pm. We will be closed on New Year's Day. We have a special four course dinner in our restaurant for $65.99 with complimentary glass of wine or beer. Cheers to 2025!
New's Eve Eve & Eve Dinner at The Fish Store

Dine locally, deliciously and early on New Year's Eve Eve and New Year's Eve at The Fish Store! Four scrumptious courses...
12/30/2024

Dine locally, deliciously and early on New Year's Eve Eve and New Year's Eve at The Fish Store! Four scrumptious courses plus one complimentary glass of wine or beer for $65.99. Includes your choice of appetizer, soup or salad, entree and dessert. This special is only good for dine in on December 30 and 31 - we will be closed on New Year's Day. We do not take reservations.
New's Eve Eve & Eve Dinner at The Fish Store

Address

836 Montauk Highway
Bayport, NY
11705

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 7pm
Tuesday 9am - 8pm
Wednesday 9am - 8pm
Thursday 9am - 8pm
Friday 9am - 9pm
Saturday 9am - 9pm
Sunday 9am - 7pm

Telephone

(631) 472-3018

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Fish Store posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Fish Store:

Videos

We are at Bayport Flower Houses today for South Shore Farmers Market! Hope to see you!

Call Now 631-472-3018!

Father’s Day Special! 🦞

Friday, Saturday and Sunday live lobster are $12..99 a pound - usually $17.99 a pound.

Beautiful jumbo soft shell crabs now at The Fish Store!!!

Just in… Wild Sockeye Salmon Filet. Sweet and Delicious Grey Sole.

Shortcuts

Share

Our Story

Started in 1978, this family business is located in the center of Bayport on the corner of Montauk Highway and Bayport Avenue. The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, dining in our new restaurant, catering and more. Along with great customer service - it is a combination that can't be beat. Through our commitment, experience and expertise The Fish Store has established a business relationship with our customers that will last a lifetime! The Fish Store is a proud member of the Bayport-Blue Point Chamber of Commerce.