The Fish Store

The Fish Store The Fish Store is home to Long Island's freshest seafood market and restaurant. Along with great customer service - it is a combination that can't be beat.
(254)

Whether cooking yourself, grabbing to go or sitting down to a delicious freshly prepared meal in our dining room - our food and friendly staff will be sure to please. Started in 1978, this family business is located in the center of Bayport on the corner of Montauk Highway and Bayport Avenue. The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, dining in our new restaurant,

catering and more. Through our commitment, experience and expertise The Fish Store has established a business relationship with our customers that will last a lifetime! The Fish Store is a proud member of the Bayport-Blue Point Chamber of Commerce.

Our festive staff is ready for you! We have everything to make your holiday delicious! Open Monday 8:30 am to 9 pmChri...
12/23/2024

Our festive staff is ready for you! We have everything to make your holiday delicious! Open Monday 8:30 am to 9 pm
Christmas Eve 8 am to 5 pm
Closed Christmas
Dining Room is closed Monday and Tuesday

It's the holiday season! Get delicious platters for all your festivities and don't forget we have merch and gift certif...
12/20/2024

It's the holiday season! Get delicious platters for all your festivities and don't forget we have merch and gift certificates for the perfect gift! Open Saturday to Monday 8:30 am - 9 pm, Christmas Eve 8 am - 5 pm and closed on Christmas. Also our dining room is closed on December 23 and 24.

From shrimp to fried zucchini sticks and everything in between! Get your holiday catering orders in NOW! One week till...
12/18/2024

From shrimp to fried zucchini sticks and everything in between! Get your holiday catering orders in NOW! One week till Christmas, call us 631-472-3018 or stop by.

Everything to make your holiday delicious! Call right now 631-472-3018 or stop by to put your order in.
12/17/2024

Everything to make your holiday delicious! Call right now 631-472-3018 or stop by to put your order in.

It's the last day of Best of Long Island voting. We are under the category of "Food", then scroll to "Fish Market" and ...
12/15/2024

It's the last day of Best of Long Island voting. We are under the category of "Food", then scroll to "Fish Market" and find us. Many thanks to everyone that took the time to vote already.

https://www.bestoflongisland.com/voting/ #/gallery?group=499333

Today! Vote and order! Order those holiday catering platters now - call 631-472-3018 or stop by. And please give us a...
12/12/2024

Today! Vote and order! Order those holiday catering platters now - call 631-472-3018 or stop by. And please give us another vote as best fish market on Long Island. Voting ends on Sunday. Click on link below, go under food and then fish market. Thanks!!!
https://www.bestoflongisland.com/voting/ #/gallery?group=499333

Vote! Vote! Vote! Vote daily until Sunday - so easy and quick. Click on the link, find category of "Food", then "Fish ...
12/10/2024

Vote! Vote! Vote! Vote daily until Sunday - so easy and quick. Click on the link, find category of "Food", then "Fish Market" and please vote for The Fish Store. We are going for Best of Long Island 12 years in a row - thank you!

https://www.bestoflongisland.com/voting/ #/gallery?group=499333

The Fish Store is ready to take your holiday catering order. The earlier you do it - the better. Stop by or call us no...
12/05/2024

The Fish Store is ready to take your holiday catering order. The earlier you do it - the better. Stop by or call us now 631-472-3018.

Last Batch for 2024!!Lobster Pot Pies - just out of the oven! Get here now because they will sell out. Perfect dinner ...
12/05/2024

Last Batch for 2024!!
Lobster Pot Pies - just out of the oven! Get here now because they will sell out. Perfect dinner for this blustery day!

We love when you post to our page!"Last night I had the seafood bisque and the buffalo shrimp. OMG! Delicious!!!"
12/03/2024

We love when you post to our page!
"Last night I had the seafood bisque and the buffalo shrimp. OMG! Delicious!!!"

When you are done Cyber Monday shopping - click on this link. Go under category of "food", "fish market", find The Fish...
12/02/2024

When you are done Cyber Monday shopping - click on this link. Go under category of "food", "fish market", find The Fish Store and vote for us as best fish market on all of Long Island! You can vote daily until December 15.
https://www.bestoflongisland.com/voting/ #/gallery?group=499333

Today! Undefeated Bayport-Blue Point High School Football is playing for Long Island Championship noon at Hofstra again...
11/29/2024

Today! Undefeated Bayport-Blue Point High School Football is playing for Long Island Championship noon at Hofstra against Wantagh. Let's Go Phantoms!

Make Black Friday Delicious! Our first ever Black Friday Special! Forget the leftover turkey and eat seafood - dine in...
11/29/2024

Make Black Friday Delicious! Our first ever Black Friday Special! Forget the leftover turkey and eat seafood - dine in or take out.

You got the turkey, but do you have the seafood? Open today, including our restaurant 9 am to 8 pm. We will be closed ...
11/27/2024

You got the turkey, but do you have the seafood? Open today, including our restaurant 9 am to 8 pm. We will be closed on Thanksgiving. And we are so very grateful to all our customers - thank you!

Thanksgiving needs fresh seafood and our platters are perfect! Regular hours Monday and Tuesday. Our market and restau...
11/25/2024

Thanksgiving needs fresh seafood and our platters are perfect! Regular hours Monday and Tuesday. Our market and restaurant will be open Wednesday 9 am to 8 pm and closed on Thanksgiving.

Congrats Bayport-Blue Point Football for winning Suffolk County Championship! Still undefeated and playing for Long Isl...
11/22/2024

Congrats Bayport-Blue Point Football for winning Suffolk County Championship! Still undefeated and playing for Long Island Championship next week. Won tonight over Miller Place 49-21. Yes Phantoms!!!

Our undefeated Phantoms Football team (including Riley) is playing tonight for the Suffolk County Championship 6 pm at S...
11/21/2024

Our undefeated Phantoms Football team (including Riley) is playing tonight for the Suffolk County Championship 6 pm at Stony Brook University against Miller Place.
Let's Go Phantoms!!!

Address

836 Montauk Highway
Bayport, NY
11705

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 7pm
Tuesday 9am - 8pm
Wednesday 9am - 8pm
Thursday 9am - 8pm
Friday 9am - 9pm
Saturday 9am - 9pm
Sunday 9am - 7pm

Telephone

(631) 472-3018

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Fish Store posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Fish Store:

Videos

Call Now 631-472-3018!

Father’s Day Special! 🦞

Friday, Saturday and Sunday live lobster are $12..99 a pound - usually $17.99 a pound.

Beautiful jumbo soft shell crabs now at The Fish Store!!!

Just in… Wild Sockeye Salmon Filet. Sweet and Delicious Grey Sole.

Shortcuts

Share

Our Story

Started in 1978, this family business is located in the center of Bayport on the corner of Montauk Highway and Bayport Avenue. The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, dining in our new restaurant, catering and more. Along with great customer service - it is a combination that can't be beat. Through our commitment, experience and expertise The Fish Store has established a business relationship with our customers that will last a lifetime! The Fish Store is a proud member of the Bayport-Blue Point Chamber of Commerce.